Classic Vanilla Pudding from Scratch - These Old Cookbooks (2024)

March 10, 2020April 18, 2023

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Classic Vanilla Pudding is a recipe that everyone should master.Making vanilla pudding from scratch is fast and easy, and the result is smooth, velvety, creamy, delicious dessert. This is better than instant pudding mix.

Classic Vanilla Pudding Recipe:

Have you ever made a homemade pudding recipe? If the answer is no, then you are missing out on one of the finer things in life. Now, don’t get me wrong, there’s nothing wrong with using a boxed pudding mix; however, there’s no comparison to a homemade, stove-top pudding.

Homemade pudding is truly a custard made with milk, egg yolks and cornstarch (to thicken). Once you learn a basic pudding recipe or technique, the sky is the limit. You can try new flavors like chocolate or peanut butter, or you can throw the pudding in a pie crust and call it a cream pie. Amaretto Sugar Cream, Lemon Meringue Pie and Peanut Butter Pie are some of my favorite pudding pie recipes.

Vanilla Pudding from Scratch

This particular old fashioned pudding recipe comes from a book of recipes of the First Mennonites in Montgomery, Indiana. I was super excited to find this recipe.With the help of my 6-year old, we went at it, and whipped up this classic vanilla pudding in no time.

How do you make pudding from scratch?

The process includes making a dry mixture and wet mixture, combining the two, and then cooking over medium heat while stirring constantly. It always amazes me how fast the pudding thickens once the mixture comes to a boil.After one minute of boiling, the pudding is thick, velvety and smooth.

For a smooth, lump-free old fashioned vanilla pudding, press the warm pudding through a sieve.

Ingredient List for Vanilla Pudding from Scratch

• Sugar
• Cornstarch
• Salt
• Milk (whole milk, if possible)
• Egg yolks
• Butter
• Vanilla Extract

How to Make Homemade Vanilla Pudding Recipe

Step By Step Instructions

1. In a small 2-Qt saucepan, combine sugar, cornstarch and salt.
2. Whisk together milk and egg yolks in a separate bowl.
3. Gradually pour in the milk mixture to the dry ingredients while whisking.
4. Cook over medium heat; stirring constantly. Add the butter to the mixture so it melts as it heats up.
5. Bring the hot milk mixture to a boil for 1 minute, stirring constantly.
6. Remove from heat, and stir in vanilla.
7. Cool slightly; press wax paper or plastic wrap against the pudding and chill completely in the refrigerator. If your pudding has clumps, you can press it though a fine mesh strainer.
8. If desired, top with fresh berries, bananas or whipped cream.

Storage Instructions

Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days.

For the full recipe steps and ingredient amounts for classic vanilla pudding, scroll to the bottom of this post in the recipe card.

Recipe FAQs

• Use granulated sugar not powdered sugar in this classic vanilla pudding.
• I highly recommend using either whole or 2% milk for a thick pudding texture.
• If your pudding has lumps, feel free to push through a sieve to make smooth. (A few lumps never killed anyone).
• To easily separate egg yolks from the whites, crack the egg in half, and use the egg shell to separate. Over a bowl, pour the yolk from one half shell to the other and the whites will seep out on their own into the bowl.
• Save the egg whites for an omelet or try your hand at homemade angel food cake.
• Homemade pudding tends to form a skin on top. To prevent this, press a piece of plastic wrap or waxed paper against the pudding before chilling in the refrigerator.
• Make pudding cups by layering easy vanilla pudding with raspberries, strawberries, or chocolate chips.
• Try this easy chocolate version of homemade pudding.
• Check out our Amazon Store for our favorite pantry essentials and other kitchen items.

Our Favorite Old-Fashioned Dessert Recipes

Old-Fashioned Dessert Recipes are our jam! Try our favorites:

Grandma’s Cherry Fluff

Caramel Corn

Date Pudding with Toffee Sauce

Grandma’s Apple Crisp

Persimmon Pudding

Old-Fashioned Oatmeal Molasses Cookies from Farmwife Feeds